86 Comments

Generally agree with you, except for Biden spending the night in Israel. We have a dicey situation with only VP Harris between us and insanity. The Speaker is #3, and who the hell even knows who that is. Maybe it would skip over and go to Sen Murray -- but the better idea is to get POTUS out of a danger area ASAP.

Expand full comment

Totally agree! Get Biden out of there, he has given too much of his kind heart already. He is giving everything he got, and people look at him like, please save us. Thank You Biden!

Expand full comment

You should be a Presidential advisor.

Well, I guess you are.😉

Back in the mid-Seventies, when I was young and foolish, I hitchhiked from Dahab (by the Gulf of Aqaba) to the Sea of Galilee, along the West Bank. At the time those areas, belonging to Egypt and Palestine, were occupied by Israel. I had no clue, at the time, I was there to scuba dive, but got distracted (and had encountered one too many sea creatures that wanted to kill me).

My only lasting memories are of the generosity and welcoming spirit of the Palestinians who offered assistance, food and shelter, and also some education and understanding.

It makes me weep to see the never-ending pain that this whole region suffers.

Let there be Peace. Stop the stupidity.

Expand full comment

Michael , your thoughts and advice always welcome! BUT Biden is doing a great job - he is one man with much responsibility and not young. Let him fly home to the mess back here without the ridiculous idea he could freely and comfortably fit into Kibbutz life for any short amount of time. Really??

Does he really need that to add to his already generous humanity?

🤔

Expand full comment

I very much appreciate the straight and honest summary of our involvement and Netanyahu’s subversive action and complicity in the abominable actions by Hamas. Continue to lead Biden!

Expand full comment

Michael. I love this. Here’s hoping some of your talking points were the president’s as well. Lastly, we have an honorable man representing the US in these visits. Thank you for sharing this with all of us

Expand full comment

Yes on all counts. You and the President are both in sync when it comes to being compassionate to all innocent people caught up in this violence, as well as pragmatic about taking concrete steps to alleviate it without ceding any ground to Hamas. People who do a loyalty test by demanding empathy for only one group of humans will not like your message any more than they liked Bidens, but when haters hate on you, you know you've done well.

Expand full comment

Thank you for your thoughtful letter. I hope you are heard. Have you ever thought about running for presidency? I am sure you would be a good one!

Expand full comment

Sadly, Michael’s too sane and far left to get a majority….. If Only !

He would have done it already if he thought he could get there.

Expand full comment

Thank you Michael for this sensitive and thoughtful post. I appreciate it immensely. You're for peace, Sally

Expand full comment

I was so relieved that you mention the British in connection with Palestine. After the Irish Free State was established they had no more "work" for the Black and Tans and their officer corps, the Auxiliaries. So they shipped them off to Palestine where they carried on murder, torture, rape, burning crops and villages, killing farm animals, imprisoning people without trial, just as they had in Ireland. But you're the first person I've found who mentions their wretched brutality--and the mess they made with maps! When I've mentioned that as the real starting point of Palestinian-battery, I hear doubting silence.

Anyway thanks from this British-born person who has lived most of her life in nyc.

Expand full comment

&JP C,

thank you had no idea of that history of the Black&Tans in Palestine. More brutality in the name of Empire.

Expand full comment

Michael, I often, very often agree with your thoughts but here you seem to be simplistically just spleen venting and ignoring the complexities of this situation. You have taken a high and mighty purist position which we leftists are so good at doing, chastising the good because it is not perfect. Gee, how good it would be if Biden could fix it all. I agree with Peggy. Let's stop the simplicities and give Biden a fucking break. He does not need at this moment, purist platitudes and historical righteousness. He needs support. Perhaps you missed his acknowledging how our thoughtless rage at 9/11, really fucked things up. I think he deserves more credit and support. We all know Netanyahu is a Trump-like sociopathic prick and I sincerely believe the Israeli masses will eventually tend to him, but good. Biden brings empathic life lessons, painfully earned. I am so glad he is there. Sometimes we leftists just need to be grateful we have the "good" and shut the fuck up.

Expand full comment

Thank you Anthony and here's how I'd put it:

1. MICHAEL is not aware that despite his good intentions, some of his "simplification" actually

ENABLES THE VERY VIOLENCE AND HARM HE DECRIES. How's that?

Much of the liberal left (to which I belong) has been played and unwittingly feeds into the cycle of violence. ARAFAT discovered twenty odd years ago that instead of making a deal, he could play the media by committing terrorist murders, force an Israeli response - and look, media, here's uniformed soldier-oppressors (Israelis) beating up on innocent street-garbed civilian Arabs. What a groove!: commit terrorism and have "bleeding" heart liberals blame Israel when they respond. Hamas has also learned, and Gazan civilians become their cannon fodder. (Let's fire missiles from a schoolyard so when Israel fires back, we get to drag out the bodies as "Israel's victims." and the media laps it up.) So YES, the anticipated Western far left reaction as a knee-jerk to "blame Israel" actually ENCOURAGES these acts. (and then Right Wing Israeli officials like Bibi feed in and do their part of course.)

2. MICHAEL's off-the-cuff reduction of Israel's stance as a consequence of being angry Jews who still can't get over the holocaust and so take it out on poor Arabs - is a sweeping characterization that avoids the present and now borders on ANTI-SEMITISM. Shame on him for that.

3. It becomes apparent that NO ONE either inside or outside this middle east conflict has it all understood. NO ONE. We liberals, like Michael, have condemned Trump and MAGA for their over simplified bigoted views to complex situations. (IE: the immigration challenges reduced to : Mexicans are thugs we must keep out, period.) But look how arm-chair Michael writes as though he's got all the players figured out. Ugh!

Expand full comment

You said what needed to be said, Michael.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Michael. You are a prophet and continue to give me, at 85, hope!!!! Grateful you were able to come to Blacksburg VA many years ago. Phyllis Taub Albritton

Expand full comment

I agree with many of your points, not all. Like your last post, you never mention Hamas; why not? If peace is to be brokered, how about begin with the return of ALL hostages. Innocents,- children, grandparents, babies, concert-goers, ALL OF THEM. How’s that for an olive-branch? Yes, Israel has its problems, for sure, but they didn’t start this war; Hamas did. If you want to paint the “ideal picture” then let’s start with the SAFE return of hostages, and then let TALKS begin. If Hamas puts down their arms and return hostages, good things could happen. If Israel puts down their arms, they’re history. Let’s get real. This shouldn’t be all on Biden’s shoulders either. Netanyahu can salvage what’s left of his career by at least TRYING to negotiate peace... but it’s a non-starter unless ALL HOSTAGES are safely returned.

Expand full comment

I fear Bibi was warned, but he let it happen let rape and slaughterand kidnapping happen, so as to stay In power and out of jail. Like Trump. I fear Bibi wants this to go on ad on a quagmire.

I think Hamas leadership chose to attack Bibi not the next gov't, because they too profit from the agony and strife. And youknow they aren't even in Gaza; they hide but in nice places e in Qatar or provably Dubai, or Lebanon or Syria or even Turkiye. A Qatar the mediator, Turkiye our NATO ally... makes me enraged. Probably Saudi too, our 9/11 financing "friend".

Those top leaders created this huge pointless cruel massacre... and how could Bibi not have learned of it prior, from the best intelligence services on earth? Nightmare

Expand full comment

Follow the money? Mindful of Eisenhower's warning.

Expand full comment

You have done it again! Consolidated the truth as no one else seems able. BRAVO 👏

Expand full comment

"A Letter from Michael Moore to President Biden" is why I subscribe to your Substack, Michael! It is "small r" respectful but there is a seething between the lines that is palpable. I am trembling after reading it because every word you wrote speaks for so very many of us...it is how we feel and what we would say to Prez Biden if we had the opportunity. When I calm down I will read it again. And I hope you will be sending a copy to the Prez's office for someone in the WH to read. So well done! So very well done! Thank you from the bottom of my heart!

Expand full comment

God forbid he should comfort Palestinians or spend the night in Gaza to stop the bombing.

Just a thought.

Expand full comment