If you watch “Collateral Murder” and are shocked, this is a perfectly natural reaction. How the discussion about it is framed however, makes a world of difference.
Speaking as a former soldier who was in the company on the ground
in the video, who would have been in this video had I not angered my
leaders and was left out of this mission, I am disappointed that this
video has been used by some to cast such stronger moral indignation on
the soldiers shown without looking at the deeper implications. It is
easy to wash our hands of this blood; it is challenging but
transformational to ask what we can do to provide alternatives.
There is strong evidence that the decisions made were not an illustration simply of demented murders rather than soldiers doing as they were trained to do; this is not a moral statement, it’s an observation based on:
1. David Finkel, a Washington Post reporter who was embedded with my unit (again, the one shown on the ground in the video) wrote a detailed account of what took place during this mission shown on this video, almost describing it word for word in his popular book, The Good Soldiers. Despite the book’s success, the outrage we are seeing came over this event only when it was seen visually and out of context rather than described in words.
2. In 2008, over 200 veterans and eye-witnesses came together to testify about many of the troubling events they witnessed in the Winter Soldier Testimonies, using many personal accounts of stories like “Collateral Murder” and worse; the mainstream media and general public took little, if any notice.
3. Discussion boards of predominantly military personal, are full of military members defending the actions of the soldier’s decisions in this video.
My aim in writing about this is to create a conversation where we can address some very serious issues; but the way that discussion has been framed probably will not change anything. For those who have been harsh towards the soldiers involved, if moral indignation is your goal, you will not accomplish much. Those who agree with you still will and those who don’t aren’t going to want to learn from your perspective.
I personally grew up learning from most of society that war was an
acceptable way to solve problems. The few anti-war voices that I heard
came across as shrill and arrogant, giving me little incentive to want
to learn from them. Since that time I have met many inspiring people
working for peace with many important ideas, inspiring me to now devote
much of my time towards peacemaking. But from the anti-war voices I
heard before my military experience, I had no interest in listening to
people talk about peace who seemed so arrogant and self-righteous.
Another important thing to note is that when I left the army a year ago I spent six months walking and biking across the country to speak about how I came to be a conscientious objector, promote the critical thinking that our common culture largely lacks, and attempt to find common ground with people of all persuasions to work towards creative ways of solving problems non-violently.
I spoke to dozens of audiences, beginning my talks by asking people to stand up if they cared about their families and friends. Then I told them that when I had asked myself the same question in high school, I was told many things would be in my best interest to do and say. I’d then tell them to repeat one of the things I was told and lead the audience in the following cadence that was sung regularly in my army experience:
I went down to the market/where all the women shop
I pulled out my machete/and I began to chop
I went down to the park/where all the children play
I pulled out my machine gun/and I began to spray
I could get audiences of even the most extreme peace activists
would typically repeat this. My goal was to show how easy it can be to
say and do horrible things when pressured by a leader telling them they
were doing it in the interest of those they care about and by the
pressure of those around them also standing and repeating. I am not
morally justifying these cadences, but I am saying that this is how the
system is and this is how it slowly eats away the consciences of
idealistic young people and if we want to change this system, we must
first understand it.
I am not morally justifying what happened in “Collateral Murder,” but I do want to explain that based on military training, what was done is to be expected; it indicates larger issues and from there, we can decide how to respond. If we instantly cast a judgment, I would argue that you are hurting your own cause.
That said, the context that the video doesn’t describe (but again, is detailed in The Good Soldiers) is that several companies were patrolling the streets. As they were searching houses, the helicopters were assigned to protect them from above. Some people have pointed out that nobody pointed a weapon at the helicopters, hence they were unprovoked. But all other debate aside, imagine for a second that you’re assigned to keep watch over a group that is busy doing something else and you see something that you think is a threat; you’ll begin to fear for their safety and for the burden it would be if you failed to protect those you were assigned to watch over. Another contextual aspect of this is that the longer video even shows that weapons were recovered from those shot. My apologies for not posting the longer version in my first post on this; here it is:
We were heavily trained with this fear-creating mindset. One part of training was having several of my leaders ask myself and other young soldiers how we would respond if somebody were to pull a weapon out in a marketplace full of civilians. If we did not say that we would fire back, despite the civilians, we got chastised for not living up to our duties as soldiers.
And this is exactly the point; the soldiers in the helicopter were acting on everything we had been heavily drilled with from the early days of basic training. If you want to keep things like this from happening, stop screaming at soldiers who are fighting in a war that most Americans advocated to begin with and instead spend your energy exposing the training that soldiers are put through and demand political and military leaders to reexamine the system that creates the callousness displayed in this video or the huge amount of our national budget that we pay for this thriving military system. Because, again, from examples like the cadence I mention above, this callousness is both rampant and intentional.
I personally refused a number of orders and eventually chose to go through the process of conscientious objection and was fortunate enough to have a lot of support from family and friends during that challenging process of leaving the military early. I was also fortunate enough to read books by Gandhi and Tolstoy while in Iraq. But for the many soldiers who don’t have that support from those around them or haven’t read books articulating peace, calling them baby-killers for acting how they were trained to is not going to make them any more likely to seek help from those claiming that war is not the answer. If you want to do something truly revolutionary, try reaching out to a soldier in compassion and show him/her that there is a better way to solve problems, real or perceived.
And that’s where this video can be helpful. It shows the huge
contradiction of what our government says we are doing—spreading
freedom and democracy—and how we are seeking to accomplish this. For
those who want to defend the soldier’s decisions in terms of
self-defense, we still have to ask the serious question that even if
these actions legitimately so, (I’m definitely not saying they were)
are we not still creating far more enemies in the process?
This video is, as the saying goes, “the nature of the beast.” Staring only at the fangs of the beast prevent us from the much needed conversation of whether or not we should be using this beast at all. Then we need to be prepared to answer what will stand in it’s place. Shock from seeing this video is natural, but please don’t miss this opportunity to use this video to talk about the much deeper implications of the nature of warfare and what it means to work for peace.
Here a just a few suggestions:
1. Look at how we teach our children… my history classes never taught that things like the dropping of the atomic bomb were morally wrong. Throughout our history we have justified killing of civilians if it helps our end goal. TEACH our kids otherwise, work towards starting peace studies programs in the schools in your counties: http://www.salsa.net/peace/conv/index.html
2. Help provide information and support to those who are within the military on ways of standing up for their beliefs through work being done with the GI Rights Hotline: http://www.girightshotline.org/
3. Become a part of the Civilian Soldier Allience, embracing those within the military or veteran communities who want to talk about their experiences and work towards other options: http://www.civsol.org/content/get-involved
4. Question the training that our government and our tax money puts our impressionable young people through. Again, if we object to this video, we need to look at what training led to it. Check out books like On Killing http://www.amazon.com/Killing-Psychological-Cost-Learning-Society/dp/0316330116 and pressure political and military leaders to reconsider the psychological methods that teach soldiers to dehumanize.
5. Question where our tax money is really going and why so much is spent on warfare: http://www.warresisters.org/pages/piechart.htm
6. Inform yourself on the deeper priorities of our society by watching for example, The Story of Stuff http://storyofstuff.org/ and ask yourself if your lifestyle is contributing to those mistaken priorities.
7. If we are repulsed by the callousness shown in this video, start removing our society’s tendency towards callousness through the movies we watch and video games we play that reinforce the very thing which repulses us when we actually see it in real life.
8. Ask to your religious leaders and work with them to ask their congregations if this video, which again shows the nature of war, lives up to what your religion teaches or if you need to actively preach and practice another way.
January 28th, 2014
In the State of the Union address tonight, President Obama is going to call for a national minimum wage of $10.10. Then in their response ...
January 21st, 2014
My New Year's Day op-ed in the New York Times seems to have kickstarted a discussion about how to make Obamacare better. I hope you ...
December 18th, 2013
This morning it was announced by the Library of Congress and the National Film Preservation Board that my first film, 'Roger & Me', has been ...
December 14th, 2013
[View the story "Michael Moore Tweets on Eve of Newtown Anniversay" on Storify]
November 9th, 2013
Click here for this week's full schedule for the State Theatre and Bijou by the Bay in Traverse City, Michigan. The day has arrived. For ...
September 10th, 2013
[View the story "John Kerry's Accidental Diplomacy" on Storify]
July 30th, 2013
Today Bradley Manning was convicted on 20 of 22 counts, including violating the Espionage Act, releasing classified information and disobeying orders. That's the bad news. ...
September 11th, 2010
OpenMike 9/11/10 Michael Moore's daily blog I am opposed to the building of the "mosque" two blocks from Ground Zero. I want it built on ...
December 14th, 2010
Yesterday, in the Westminster Magistrates Court in London, the lawyers for WikiLeaks co-founder Julian Assange presented to the judge a document from me stating that ...
May 12th, 2011
"The Nazis killed tens of MILLIONS. They got a trial. Why? Because we're not like them. We're Americans. We roll different." – Michael Moore in ...
November 22nd, 2011
This past weekend I participated in a four-hour meeting of Occupy Wall Street activists whose job it is to come up with the vision and ...
September 22nd, 2011
I encourage everyone I know to never travel to Georgia, never buy anything made in Georgia, to never do business in Georgia. I will ask ...
December 16th, 2010
Dear Swedish Government: Hi there -- or as you all say, Hallå! You know, all of us here in the U.S. love your country. Your ...
November 2nd, 2010
This letter contains (almost) no criticisms of how the Democrats have brought this day of reckoning upon themselves. That -- and where to go from ...