Here Comes Trouble: Stories from My Life

"Outstanding…Moore Triumphs! Publishers Weekly

Mike & Friends Blog

Michael Moore

Michael Moore is an Academy-Award winning filmmaker and best-selling author

September 30th, 2010 10:04 AM

Dwight Was Right

Today's OpenMike blog

So...it turns out President Eisenhower wasn't making up all that stuff about the military-industrial complex.

That's what you'll conclude if you read Bob Woodward's new book, Obama's War. (You can read excerpts of it here, here and here.) You thought you voted for change when you cast a ballot for Barack Obama? Um, not when it comes to America occupying countries that don't begin with a "U" and an "S."

In fact, after you read Woodward's book, you'll split a gut every time you hear a politician or a government teacher talk about "civilian control over the military." The only people really making the decisions about America's wars are across the river from Washington in the Pentagon. They wear uniforms. They have lots of weapons they bought from the corporations they will work for when they retire.

For everyone who supported Obama in 2008, it's reassuring to find out he understands we have to get out of Afghanistan. But for everyone who's worried about Obama in 2010, it's scary to find out that what he thinks should be done may not actually matter. And that's because he's not willing to stand up to the people who actually run this country.

And here's the part I don't even want to write -- and none of you really want to consider:

It matters not whom we elect. The Pentagon and the military contractors call the shots. The title "Commander in Chief" is ceremonial, like "Employee of the Month" at your local Burger King.

Everything you need to know can be found in just two paragraphs from Obama's War. Here's the scene: Obama is meeting with his National Security Council staff on the Saturday after Thanksgiving last year. He's getting ready to give a big speech announcing his new strategy for Afghanistan. Except...the strategy isn't set yet. The military has presented him with just one option: escalation. But at the last minute, Obama tells everyone, hold up -- the door to a plan for withdrawal isn't closed.

The brass isn't having it:

"Mr. President," [Army Col. John Tien] said, "I don't see how you can defy your military chain here. We kind of are where we are. Because if you tell General McChrystal, 'I got your assessment, got your resource constructs, but I've chosen to do something else,' you're going to probably have to replace him. You can't tell him, 'Just do it my way, thanks for your hard work.' And then where does that stop?"

The colonel did not have to elaborate. His implication was that not only McChrystal but the entire military high command might go in an unprecedented toppling -- Gates; Adm. Mike Mullen, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff; and Gen. David H. Petraeus, then head of U.S. Central Command. Perhaps no president could weather that, especially a 48-year-old with four years in the U.S. Senate and 10 months as commander in chief.

And, well, the rest is history. Three days later Obama announced the escalation at West Point. And he became our newest war president.

But here's the question Woodward doesn't answer: Why, exactly, can't a president weather ending a war, even if he has to fire all his generals to do it? It's right there in Article II, Section 2 of the Constitution: The President's in charge of the military. And so is Congress: the army can't just march over to the Treasury Department and steal the money for wars. Article I, Section 9 says Congress has to appropriate it.

In the real world, though, the Constitution's just a piece of paper. In the real world, a President who fired his top military in order to stop a war would be ruined before you could say "bloodless coup." The Washington Post (filled with ads from Boeing and Northrop Grumman) would scream about how he was the reincarnation of Neville Chamberlain. Fox and CNN (filled with "experts" who work for think tanks funded by Raytheon and General Dynamics) would say he was a girly-man who had to be impeached. And Congress (which experienced its own escalation in lobbying from defense contractors just as the Afghanistan escalation was being decided) might well do it. (By the way, if you want to listen to Lyndon Johnson talk in 1964 about how he might be impeached if he didn't follow the military-industrial complex's orders and escalate the war in Vietnam, just go here.)

So here's your assignment for tonight: Watch Eisenhower's famous farewell speech. And then start thinking about how we can tame this beast. The Soviet Union had its own military-industrial complex, which is one reason they got into Afghanistan...which is one reason there's no more Soviet Union. It happened to them.

Don't think it can happen to us?

Creative Commons License This content is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License

You must log in to comment.

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Log in | Register

(3/3) Stay tuned for 950K, 960K & 970K winners to be announced soon! Names are drawn from all 970K of u!

Feb 22nd
12:47 PM
Retweet This

(2/3) Winner @ 940K is Tisha Ward @Tisha775 - congrats, Tisha! Her $1K goes to her local public library http://t.co/bnSzV6oJ

Feb 22nd
12:46 PM
Retweet This

(1/3) With every 10K new followers I get, I choose a winner from ALL my followers and donate $1,000 to a charity of their choice

Feb 22nd
12:45 PM
Retweet This

RT @fupsduck: @MMFlint News flash: Mitt Romney pledges executive order mandating tree height regulation in all 50 states using Michigan ...

Feb 21st
5:26 PM
Retweet This

RT @TheDailyEdge: If #Santorum Is Right that 'Satan Is Targeting America,' It's Not Much of a Leap to Think He's Dressing As a Jesus Fre ...

Feb 21st
4:52 PM
Retweet This

New Protest Idea #2: The 99% haven't seen standard of living rise since the '80s, so it's Flock of Seagulls time: http://t.co/yXIVT1a2

Feb 21st
4:42 PM
Retweet This

#OWS has inspired whole new and profoundly powerful ways 2 protest. Try this in your town: The Silence Protest! http://t.co/OnA9dHhn

Feb 21st
4:38 PM
Retweet This

"@tonywee27: @MMFlint u being a native son o MI what do u like more? Be honest-great lakes or little inland lakes?\355\240\274" Oh, the lil' cute ones!

Feb 21st
4:26 PM
Retweet This

Santorum appeals to that sad minority in MI that gave u Fr. Coughlin, Michigan Militia, Ted Nugent, Obama-snubber goalie Tim Thomas & napalm

Feb 21st
1:31 PM
Retweet This

Crowds for Romney & Santorum in MI are small. Obama's crowds were ten - twenty - times as large.

Feb 21st
1:28 PM
Retweet This

TheMichiganParadox: We gave the world Aretha, Diana, Stevie, Madonna, Eminem WhiteStripes Iggy. We also gave u Mitt singing WhoLetTheDogsOut

Feb 21st
12:10 PM
Retweet This

Lenore Romney, Mitt's mom, won the Republican primary for U.S. Senator from Michigan in 1970, but lost the gen election. She was pro-choice.

Feb 21st
3:14 AM
Retweet This

The most positive aspect of the primaries so far is how FEW people r showing up 2 declare themselves a Republican. This "should" bode well.

Feb 21st
1:20 AM
Retweet This

I mean, if logic & a rational order of the universe existed, then of course Obama is going to smoke these guys. But I live in the USA.

Feb 21st
1:18 AM
Retweet This

If Romney's the nominee, many Dems & indies will vote for him. If it's Santorum, he will lead a religious crusade of millions. #dontgetcocky

Feb 20th
11:44 PM
Retweet This

My pause during interview: I was going 2 make a joke about how easy it will b beating these Repubs-but I stopped cause I don't believe that.

Feb 20th
11:42 PM
Retweet This

Ha! I got my Christian Conservative Tim wires crossed! Tim Thomas of the Bruins went 2 my h.s., not Tim Tebow. I'm all Timmed out now.

Feb 20th
11:38 PM
Retweet This

Going live now with Rachel Maddow on MSNBC. Topic: native sons of Michigan and how high are our trees?

Feb 20th
10:29 PM
Retweet This

On my way to be with Rachel live in the studio @MSNBC. Streets of New York are empty. Everyone either at Garden or home watching Jeremy Lin.

Feb 20th
9:17 PM
Retweet This

RT @ariannahuff: For President's Day, check out Marlo Thomas' slideshow of the many women leading nations across the world http://t.co/d ...

Feb 20th
7:14 PM
Retweet This

With every 10,000 new twitter followers I get, I choose a winner from ALL my followers and donate $1,000 to a charity of their choice. The winner at 940K is...

Feb 22nd
8:06 PM
Read More

Get your Miami Vice jacket or leg warmers and head down to the Outback Steakhouse in Miami Lakes, Florida at 3:00 PM today: Dress Up Like the'80s and...

Feb 21st
3:54 PM
Read More

Occupy, environmental and other activists: join a live, free discussion tonight at 7:00 PM ET with Heidi Boghosian, executive director of the National Lawyers...

Feb 21st
10:21 AM
Read More

I'll be on the Rachel Maddow Show tonight at 9:00 PM ET/6:00 PM PT (rerun at Midnight ET/9:00 PM PT) to share my thoughts about the Republican circus tent...

Feb 20th
8:41 PM
Read More

The revolution will not be televised (unless we make our own TV shows): Occupy TV: Demonstrators take their case from Lincoln Park to broadcast (video)...

Feb 20th
12:15 PM
Read More

Held Hostage by Bank of America ...by Micah Hauptman www.michaelmoore.com Public Citizen filed a petition with the Federal Reserve and the Financial Stability...

Feb 19th
5:55 PM
Read More

The .0000063% Election: How the Politics of the Super Rich Became American Politics | MichaelMoore. www.michaelmoore.com Electoral politics and the 2012...

Feb 19th
3:20 PM
Read More

Hungry for Freedom, Starving for Justice: a story of hunger striker Adnan Khader ...by Mira Dabit michaelmoore.com Mr. Newt Gingrich believes we are invented....

Feb 18th
9:46 AM
Read More

The Imperial Way: American Decline in Perspective, Part 2 ...by Noam Chomsky www.michaelmoore.com While the principles of U.S. imperial domination have...

Feb 18th
9:16 AM
Read More

What Politico’s ‘Wisconsin 1848’ Union Screw-Up Reveals ...by Mike Elk www.michaelmoore.com Yesterday was a red letter day for labor journalism, as Politico...

Feb 17th
1:50 PM
Read More

How Does the 1% Exploit America? Find Out in 1 Minute (VIDEO) ...by Robert Greenwald www.michaelmoore.com Even in an Occupy world, most Americans don’t know...

Feb 16th
6:40 PM
Read More

I'll be on NPR's Talk of the Nation today to talk about the new Oscar rules for feature documentaries: Talk of the Nation : NPR www.npr.org...

Feb 16th
10:03 AM
Read More

“Losing” the World: American Decline in Perspective, Part 1 ...by Noam Chomsky michaelmoore.com American decline is real, though the apocalyptic vision...

Feb 15th
8:13 PM
Read More

From Occupied Palestine to Occupy DC ...by Mira Dabit michaelmoore.com After Newt Gingrich said Palestinians were invented people, people have been joking...

Feb 15th
7:54 PM
Read More

RevolutionTruth Live Panels revolutiontruth.org Occupying Beyond Divisions: Anarchy, Black Bloc and Protests: A RevolutionTruth Panel Discussion - February...

Feb 15th
6:31 PM
Read More

Labor Reporting in the Face of Danger ...by Mike Elk www.michaelmoore.com The use of scab workers is a sore on the labor movement. And, as I recently...

Feb 15th
6:12 PM
Read More

Bradley Manning Support Network » Call the Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta. Sign the petition. www.bradleymanning.org Every week from now until the court...

Feb 15th
1:43 PM
Read More

DO SOMETHING today in New York City at 12:00 noon -- meet at Dag Hammarskjold Plaza for a march to Sen. Chuck Schumer's office: Don't Break...

Feb 14th
9:54 AM
Read More

The Long Road to Peace -- and a Short Film Nomination ...by Terry George www.huffingtonpost.com Our film The Shore is the story of one small act of...

Feb 13th
6:24 PM
Read More

350 | Tell Your Senators: Reject the Pipeline! act.350.org Right now, the Senate is considering legislation to resurrect Keystone XL, overriding President...

Feb 13th
3:53 PM
Read More

The GOP's Little Father Coughlins ...by Joe Lapointe www.michaelmoore.com Those of us who grew up Catholic (including those of us who served Latin Mass...

Feb 13th
2:39 PM
Read More

An Anniversary – Heart-Sick and SiCKO ...by Donna Smith michaelmoore.com Just a few years ago, my dad died on February 13. It was just one day short of he...

Feb 12th
9:41 PM
Read More

Trying to Catch His Breath With a Hole-Ridden Safety Net | Scientific American blogs.scientificamerican.com Uninsured people look just like everyone else. My...

Feb 12th
7:48 PM
Read More

New York Times on Future of Government Safety Net, Misses Growth and Health Care Stories ...by Dean www.michaelmoore.com The NYT had a thoughtful piece on...

Feb 12th
7:03 PM
Read More

I wrote a short story on how I became a filmmaker. It's called 'Gratitude': 'Gratitude' | MichaelMoore.com www.michaelmoore.com I...

Feb 11th
5:33 PM
Read More

A 75th Anniversary for the American Dream, a 25-Year Anniversary for Me www.michaelmoore.com On this day 25 years ago, in 1987, I became a filmmaker. It was...

Feb 11th
12:10 PM
Read More

From Michael Hastings, author of 'The Operators' about Afghanistan: The Afghanistan Report the Pentagon Doesn't Want You to Read | Rolling...

Feb 10th
7:11 PM
Read More

Fact That No One Likes Him May Be Hurting Romney « Borowitz Report www.borowitzreport.com DENVER (The Borowitz Report) – Exit polls from last night’s...

Feb 10th
11:19 AM
Read More

Silent State ...by Peter van Buren, State Department FSO www.michaelmoore.com The number of cases in play suggests an organized strategy ... The Obama...

Feb 9th
2:25 PM
Read More

Angelides: 'Gluttons of privilege' rule Wall Street www.newsreview.com "The Wall Street reactionaries are not satisfied with being rich. They...

Feb 9th
9:18 AM
Read More

Subscribe to Mike's Blog RSS

Click here to suggest an article

Mike's Blog

See More Blogs

Vew the archives

View older articles