Here Comes Trouble: Stories from My Life

"Outstanding…Moore Triumphs! Publishers Weekly

Mike & Friends Blog

Mara Verheyden-Hilliard

Mara Verheyden-Hilliard is Executive Director of the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund

November 14th, 2011 4:33 PM

The Brooklyn Bridge Mass Arrest Was Unconsitutional

When more than seven hundred New Yorkers left their apartments on the morning of Saturday October 1 to join in a march of thousands from the Occupy Wall Street encampment to downtown Brooklyn they had no idea that they were just hours away from being handcuffed and hauled off to jail in one of the largest mass false arrests in recent years.

The police are given the extraordinary authority to deprive you of your liberty, arrest you, put you in jail. But to lawfully exercise that authority there are some basic requirements that the Constitution mandates be met – requirements that the NYPD completely ignored when they arrested everyone on October 1.  A review of protest cases of the past four decades shows that the law is on the side of those who were arrested.

The march participants were in state of shock and disbelief when they were suddenly arrested half way across the Brooklyn Bridge by the same NYPD officers and top commanders who had led them out onto the bridge walking east toward Brooklyn. The police had their backs turned toward the peaceful demonstrators as they all walked toward Brooklyn.

About halfway across the bridge the police did an about face, stopped the march, trapped people, refused to let them go, and arrested them, all without probable cause to arrest.

The unsuspecting demonstrators learned first hand that the NYPD had sprung an old trick called “Trap and Arrest.” The NYPD has a long history of using this tactic.

The nation’s capital banned the tactic as a result of successful class action litigation by the Partnership for Civil Justice on behalf of more than a 1,000 people who had been falsely arrested in Washington D.C. in 2000 and 2002 by police who used the “trap and arrest” tactic to shut down mass assembly protest.

The 700 people who were mass arrested on the Brooklyn Bridge spent a good part of Saturday night October 1 handcuffed on buses before they were taken into jail and processed. They were released into the pre-dawn hours of Sunday morning.

Now those arrested are being forced to return to court to face baseless charges. These are working people, students, people looking for jobs, who must face the hardship of being prosecuted, and who did nothing wrong.

The Manhattan District attorney Cyrus Vance, Jr. has received a huge number of letters asking that he drop the charges against those arrested. That would be the right thing to do. Please add your voice to those calling for the charges to be dismissed.

What is the “Trap and Arrest Tactic”?

The trap and arrest tactic is an unconstitutional tactic in which police lines are used to surround a demonstration group that includes people who have committed no violence or obstructive acts; and the police conduct a mass arrest in the absence of fair warning or notice.

Forty years ago, Vietnam war demonstrators were subjected to the same illegal tactics.

In 1971, a group of anti-war demonstrators were arrested on the Capitol steps after police initially stopped marchers, but then stood aside and permitted them to proceed to the steps, then trapped and arrested them. The Court acknowledged that the police had issued what amounted to an “unwritten permit” by allowing the march to proceed. The Chief of Police in Washington, D.C. was held liable for the false arrests.

In 1961, when students in Louisiana were demonstrating against Jim Crow apartheid, they too were subject to false arrest after being granted permission to demonstrate. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that, “to sustain [a] conviction for demonstrating where they told [them they] could, 'would be to sanction an indefensible sort of entrapment by the State - convicting a citizen for exercising a privilege which the State had clearly told him was available to him.'"

In short, the government cannot permit people to march – and then arrest them because they do so, and certainly not without fair notice.

“Fair Notice” and Opportunity to Comply

“Fair notice,” as that term is interpreted constitutionally in the context of protests, requires the police to issue orders, followed by a meaningful opportunity to comply. Only those who refuse to comply after fair notice may be constitutionally subject to arrest.  

If you don’t hear an order, you can’t comply with it -- or fail to comply with it for that matter.

As the Court wrote in one of the class action mass arrest cases my office litigated, charging hundreds of individuals with failure to obey a police order without first ordering them “is nothing short of ludicrous.”

The NYPD issued edited videos purporting to show notice being given to demonstrators at the base of the bridge that they shouldn’t cross the bridge. One little bullhorn is supposed to have carried to the ears of the thousands of chanting demonstrators, among whom over 700 would be arrested.

In the Vietnam-era case, the Court wrote that the Police Chief “should have been aware that the hand-held bull horn he testified he used to give his orders was not powerful enough to reach the crowd.”

The Court said that constitutionally required “fair notice” is “notice reasonably likely to have reached all of the crowd despite any noise the demonstrators may have been making.”

Earlier this year, Appellate Judge Richard Posner held it was impossible for handheld bullhorns to provide fair notice to hundreds of anti-war marchers who were mass arrested by Chicago police.

After the NYPD made a show of using one bullhorn to give an order inaudible to those only feet away - - and impossible to be heard by the thousands of people supposedly subject to the order --   the police turned around, led, and apparently permitted the march onto the roadway of the bridge.

Halfway across the bridge they formed police lines trapping the group. They arrested over 700 for being present on a bridge which the police had just led them upon and from which the police would not let them exit. This was a premeditated, planned, scripted and calculated effort to sweep the streets of protestors and disrupt a growing protest movement in New York.

In 2004, the Manhattan D.A. did not prosecute and instead dismissed charges against 227 arrested protestors, where he found that “[t]he police likely created the impression that the march had official sanction.”

Thousands are calling upon D.A. Vance to follow this precedent and dismiss all of the Brooklyn Bridge mass arrest charges. It’s not just the right thing to do. It’s what the Constitution and justice require.

The Partnership for Civil Justice Fund (PCJF) is a not-for-profit constitutional rights legal and educational organization which, among other things, seeks to ensure constitutional accountability within police practices and government transparency in operations.
The PCJF has filed the class action lawsuit seeking to end the NYPD’s use of the trap and arrest tactic and to vindicate the rights of those mass arrested on the Brooklyn Bridge. It litigated class action cases in which more than 1,000 persons were falsely arrested during protests in Washington, D.C., resulting in settlements totaling $22 million and major changes in police practices. The PCJF previously brought the successful litigation in New York challenging the 2004 ban on protests in the Great Lawn of Central Park. It is counsel with the National Lawyers Guild in Oakland, CA challenging police mass arrest tactics. The PCJF previously uncovered and disclosed that the D.C. police employed an unlawful domestic spying and agent provocateur program in which officers were sent on long-term assignments posing as political activists and infiltrated lawful and peaceful groups. For more information go to: www.JusticeOnline.org.

You must log in to comment.

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Log in | Register

If you have a moment today, I hope you can read the obituary for my father Francis (Frank) Moore, who died this past Saturday at the age of 92: Francis...

Apr 22nd
6:33 PM
Read More

My father, Francis (Frank) Moore, passed away this morning a few months shy if his 93rd birthday. He was a great dad I am blessed to have had him in my life. I...

Apr 20th
2:58 AM
Read More

Time to put the cuffs on Chris Christie -- not for the bridge scandal, but for this: Chris Christie's $300m pension proposal broke state anti-corruption...

Apr 18th
7:31 PM
Read More

George W. Bush Debuts New Paintings Of Dogs, Friends, Ghost Of Iraqi Child That Follows Him... www.theonion.com President Bush has a new hobby -- painting! --...

Apr 17th
7:28 PM
Read More

Big new story from David Sirota and Pando on top Christie adviser and appearance of corruption at New Jersey's pension fund: REVEALED: Gov....

Apr 17th
12:41 PM
Read More

FBI Uncovers Al-Qaeda Plot To Just Sit Back And Enjoy Collapse Of United States www.theonion.com WASHINGTON—The FBI announced today that it has uncovered a...

Apr 15th
3:28 PM
Read More

Revealed: Rahm Emanuel's top donor bought stock in Marriott just before it was awarded huge contract pando.com As schools are closed and pensions cut,...

Apr 9th
2:00 PM
Read More

I'll be at First Time Fest today in New York City at the screening of my first film, Roger & Me. Loews Village 7 at 12:30 pm. Come see it on the big...

Apr 5th
9:48 AM
Read More

Revealed: Rahm Emanuel cuts public pensions, diverts money to benefit campaign donors pando.com If you've read the financial news out of Chicago the last...

Apr 4th
2:19 PM
Read More

Please take a moment today to think of Casey Austin Sheehan, son of Cindy and Patrick, who was murdered by U.S. foreign policy in Sadr City, Baghdad ten years...

Apr 4th
2:00 PM
Read More

ICYMI - I've joined this "thunderclap" to support the Connecticut legislators who voted yes on last year's Act Concerning Gun Violence...

Apr 3rd
7:38 PM
Read More

I've joined this "thunderclap" to support the Connecticut legislators who voted yes on last year's Act Concerning Gun Violence Prevention...

Apr 2nd
8:27 PM
Read More

I am opposed to the death penalty, but to every rule there is usually an exception, and in this case I hope the criminals at General Motors will be arrested...

Apr 1st
3:55 PM
Read More

How Long Some in the US Will Survive Under New Health Law ...by Donna Smith www.michaelmoore.com Those who must access care to live and can afford it are not...

Mar 31st
10:13 PM
Read More

Last night, The Good Wife on the East Coast started 40 minutes late due to the overrun of the NCAA basketball game. If you had your DVR set for the show, you...

Mar 24th
5:41 PM
Read More

Watching films today, looking for the ones I'm going to pick for my film festival this summer. I (and a whole bunch of others!) have this thing we put on...

Mar 23rd
4:48 PM
Read More

When the U.S. Health Care System Keeps Killing, Who Cares Enough to Fight? ...by Donna Smith www.michaelmoore.com We have largely forgotten that people are at...

Mar 21st
5:56 PM
Read More

Tell the White House not to give up on Dr. Vivek Murthy's nomination as Surgeon General despite the ferocious opposition from the NRA: Don't give...

Mar 21st
5:38 PM
Read More

This criminal would never see a jail cell, nor would his cronies. In fact, they'd later be rewarded with re-election: Presidential Address on War with...

Mar 19th
9:40 PM
Read More

The crime of the century -- our invasion & slaughter in Iraq -- started 11 years ago tonite in this 7pm (ET) hour, March 19th, 2003: CNN Coverage of...

Mar 19th
9:08 PM
Read More

Washington’s Back-to-the-Future Military Policies in Africa ...by Nick Turse www.michaelmoore.com Nick Turse is an award-winning journalist, historian,...

Mar 17th
4:59 PM
Read More

"I think democracy is the most revolutionary thing in the world." -- Tony Benn, 1925-2014 Tony Benn in 'Sicko'

Mar 14th
10:07 AM
Read More

RIP Tony Benn, one of the UK's greatest leaders: Tony Benn, veteran Labour politician, dies aged 88 www.theguardian.com Former cabinet minister died at...

Mar 14th
9:53 AM
Read More

Please read this important story from K. Ford K.: Am I the Face of the New American Middle Class? www.huffingtonpost.com I began to feel I had slipped so low...

Mar 13th
2:24 PM
Read More

Yesterday Dianne Feinstein revealed that the CIA has been spying on the Senate Intelligence Committee. This is all about the report the committee has produced...

Mar 12th
6:48 PM
Read More

Health Care for All Colorado has brought Mercy Killers, a show written and performed by Michael Milligan about our murderous for-profit healthcare system, to...

Mar 10th
1:08 PM
Read More

Health Care Dramas that Sting and Why We Have to Watch ...by Donna Smith www.michaelmoore.com The realities Milligan has written into the show cut deep into...

Mar 10th
1:02 PM
Read More

Did you know the Lehrer Newshour on PBS has been produced for 20 years by a company owned by conservative cable billionaire John Malone? Me neither. After...

Mar 7th
8:39 PM
Read More

Mr. Obama, if int’l law is so damn crucial . . . | RootsAction.org act.rootsaction.org The Russian intervention deserves criticism. But let’s be clear. The...

Mar 6th
1:21 PM
Read More

Subscribe to Mike's Blog RSS

Click here to suggest an article

Mike's Blog

See More Blogs

Vew the archives

View older articles