Here Comes Trouble: Stories from My Life

"Outstanding…Moore Triumphs! Publishers Weekly

Mike & Friends Blog

Wendell Potter

Wendell Potter is a health insurance industry whistleblower and author of 'Deadly Spin: An Insurance Company Insider Speaks Out on How Corporate PR Is Killing Health Care and Deceiving Americans'

February 8th, 2012 2:56 PM

The Battle for Vermont's Health -- And Why It Matters for the Rest of the Country

You can't see them. They're hidden from view and probably always will be. But the health insurance industry's big guns are in place and pointed directly at the citizens of Vermont.

Health insurers were not able to stop the state's drive last year toward a single-payer health care system, which insurers have spent millions to scare Americans into believing would be the worst thing ever. Despite the ceaseless spin, Vermont lawmakers last May demonstrated they could not be bought nor intimidated when they became the first in the nation to pass a bill that will probably establish a single-payer beachhead in the U.S.

When he signed Act 48 into law on May 27, surrounded by dozens of state residents who worked for many years to achieve universal coverage, Gov. Peter Shumlin expressed great pride in what had been accomplished.

"We gather here today to launch the first single payer system in America, to do in Vermont what has taken too long -- to have a health care (system) that is the best in the world, that treats health care as a right and not a privilege, where health care follows the individual, not the employer," Shumlin said.

The problem for Shumlin and his allies is this: It will take five years before Vermont can fully implement its new system, partly because the federal health care reform law prohibits states from undertaking more far-reaching reforms until 2017 unless granted waivers from the feds to do so. And though Vermont's Congressional delegation is on board to pursue a waiver that would let the state set up a single payer system two years from now, the insurance industry's friends in Washington are not keen to let that happen. That's because they want to use those five years to persuade Vermonters that they really don't want to go the single payer route after all.

During my 20 years as a health insurance PR executive, I was involved in numerous efforts to make the very term "single payer" toxic to most Americans. We even spent hundreds of thousands of premium dollars in 2007 to help finance the operation of a front group, called Health Care America, for the sole purpose of trashing a movie -- Michael Moore's Sicko -- that put single payer systems abroad in a favorable light. You can rest assured that the industry will spend much, much more to make sure that Vermont does not succeed.

I have observed in Vermont over the past several days just how the invisible hand of the insurance industry is working. Insurers know their efforts will be more effective if they can get others -- third party advocates, they call them -- to carry out them out. I recognized the campaign because the tactics are the same as those used in previous attempts to kill reforms insurers don't like.

Part of the strategy is to get key groups of individuals to begin raising doubts, to get Vermonters to second-guess themselves. Among the first groups the insurers have targeted are those most easily spooked -- certain business owners and physicians, especially specialists who thrive in the current system.

Last Wednesday, legislators got a sampling of what they're in for. At a hearing on creation of the state's health care exchange, or marketplace -- mandated by the federal reform law -- employers worried about losing the ability to choose from numerous competing insurers. And they worried too about not being able to shift their employees into benefit plans with high deductibles. Insurers and employers have been collaborating for the past several years in a mutually beneficial effort to shift more of us into high-deductible policies. The higher the deductible, the less insurers and employers have to pay for our care. This collaboration has been so successful that increasing numbers of American families filing for bankruptcy are, at least theoretically, insured.

At a hearing a few days earlier in Rutland, this one for health care providers, several physicians were, wittingly or not, using some of the same industry talking points I used to write for insurers' allies.

Dermatologist Dan McCauliffe was one of several doctors there who suggested that patients needed to pay more -- not less -- out of their own pocket for care. Ironically, this skin doctor joined other physician specialists in arguing that health care costs would never stabilize until patients had "more skin in the game," a term my former colleagues used frequently as we tried to spin the "advantages" of high-deductible plans. According to statistics from the American Medical Association, dermatologists are among the highest paid specialists, making on average more than $230,000.

So why do insurers care so much about Vermont? Even though Vermont is a small state where most for-profit insurers have little business, the insurers don't want a single state to go single payer. Just last week, single payer advocates in California fell just a few votes short of getting a bill to the floor of the Senate for a vote. If Vermont succeeds, California lawmakers might actually get the votes they need.

Health insurers make enormous amounts of money off of us, something they cannot do so effectively in other countries, especially Canada. The four largest insurers, United, WellPoint, Aetna and CIGNA, reported earning a combined $11 billion on nearly $220 billion in revenues last year. For years insurers have been successful in persuading Americans to believe something that is at best debatable -- that they play a useful role in the U.S. health care system. They are nervous that if Vermont proves to the rest of the country that health insurers are about as useful as teats on a boar, they might have to figure out another way to make a few billion bucks.

You must log in to comment.

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Log in | Register

Any suggestions for songs to download to iPod for tonight's walk? 10pm ET 7pm PT

May 23rd
8:52 PM
Retweet This

100,000protesters in Montreal support student strikers: http://t.co/fpOCdINb Trying 2 stop the slippery slope 2 US: http://t.co/XoPiP08Z

May 23rd
7:19 PM
Retweet This

Study Finds Fox News Viewers Least Informed Of All Viewers (Did we really need a study for this?) http://t.co/8h9suZs2

May 23rd
3:21 PM
Retweet This

Oh, the price of empire (nearly $1 trillion): http://t.co/21gh9DZe

May 23rd
12:18 PM
Retweet This

Reports say Michael McKean has been moved from critical 2 serious.Broken leg, abrasions, cuts,etc. Here's 2 a speedy recovery for a gr8 guy.

May 22nd
11:28 PM
Retweet This

RT @OccupyWallStNYC: "If you’re a banker, don’t lose my money." http://t.co/IRiCOZON #JPMorgan #FAIL

May 22nd
11:15 PM
Retweet This

Back from the walk. Along the way news@11 tv crews on corner. Actor Michael McKean had been hit by an out of control car. He's @ St. Luke's.

May 22nd
11:11 PM
Retweet This

Here's a few pix from our photo album: http://t.co/ZF9WSiSS & from the NY Times: http://t.co/iLnPG3rL Also: http://t.co/93Dnncns

May 22nd
9:56 PM
Retweet This

8 years ago tonight, Fahrenheit 9/11 won the top prize at the Cannes Film Festival. It's difficult 2 describe the array of emotions we felt!

May 22nd
9:51 PM
Retweet This

Who's still walking with me? Day 66. 10pm ET.

May 22nd
8:41 PM
Retweet This

Is there any politician who isn't on the take? Seriously. Let's start a list(this shouldn't take long): 1.BernieSanders 2.BarbaraLee Others?

May 22nd
10:40 AM
Retweet This

CORRECTION: Wall St & Bain have given $565,000 to Newark Mayor Cory Booker's campaigns http://t.co/aDA3aj2E ...

May 22nd
10:26 AM
Retweet This

And I tweeted this last night: BREAKING: Cory Booker rushes into burning issue to save Mitt Romney.

May 22nd
9:50 AM
Retweet This

Then,Booker goes on Meet the Press & defends Bain & Wall St & says Obama, Dems should stop attacking rich investors http://t.co/D710cbGb

May 22nd
9:47 AM
Retweet This

"@slksputnik: Seems like you've managed 2 do a walk every day since u began. Have u missed any days? If not kudos. Hell kudos anyway." Nope!

May 22nd
8:02 AM
Retweet This

BREAKING: Cory Booker rushes into burning issue to save Mitt Romney.

May 22nd
1:43 AM
Retweet This

An afternoon walk in the rain today: 3:30pm ET Getting wet is good for the soul. Or something like that.

May 21st
3:19 PM
Retweet This

RT @johnknefel: Scott Olsen just returned his medals. Huge crowd response #ows #nonato

May 20th
6:35 PM
Retweet This

"Welcome, Nato, to Chicago's police state ... a 'new normal' of militarized social control" http://t.co/Hspeagq9

May 20th
6:27 PM
Retweet This

Spinning the Supreme Court's 'Obamacare' decision ...by Wendell Potter www.michaelmoore.com If the mandate goes, the insurance industry want to...

May 23rd
2:34 PM
Read More

Amy Goodman and Democracy Now report on vets returning their medals at the NATO summit in Chicago: "No NATO, No War": U.S. Veterans of Iraq and...

May 23rd
7:29 AM
Read More

War Pay: The Nearly $1 Trillion National Security Budget ...by Chris Hellman www.michaelmoore.com Americans overwhelmingly think that national security...

May 23rd
7:14 AM
Read More

Eight years ago today, 'Fahrenheit 9/11' won the Palme d'Or at the Cannes Film Festival: BBC NEWS | Entertainment | Anti-Bush film tops Cannes...

May 22nd
8:25 PM
Read More

Charles Koch + Roger Ailes = Ohio University? ...by Robert Greenwald www.michaelmoore.com Why would Ohio U host a talk by the likes of Roger Ailes? Maybe we...

May 21st
4:20 PM
Read More

Let’s End Polluter Welfare ...by Sen. Bernie Sanders www.michaelmoore.com American taxpayers are set to give away over $110 billion dollars to the oil, gas,...

May 21st
1:19 PM
Read More

How Rural America Got Fracked ...by Ellen Cantarow www.michaelmoore.com This rural landscape is becoming part of a vast assembly line in the corporate race...

May 21st
1:16 PM
Read More

Donna Summer Dies of 9/11-Related Contamination ...by Reggie Cervantes www.michaelmoore.com Only when a celebrity like Donna dies does the world notice what...

May 19th
12:34 AM
Read More

Watch Tom Morello and National Nurses United right now in a rally and concert to tax Wall Street and heal America, live from Chicago's Daley Plaza: ...

May 18th
2:25 PM
Read More

ICYMI, I'll be speaking with Cornel West in a special benefit for New York City's Brecht Forum tonight, Friday, May 18th at 7:00 PM at Hunter...

May 18th
1:01 PM
Read More

DO SOMETHING today in Chicago: Join National Nurses United and Tom Morello in a rally to heal America and tax Wall Street, 12:00 Noon at Daley Plaza: Nurses...

May 18th
5:38 AM
Read More

Today is the tenth anniversary of the premiere of my film Bowling for Columbine, at the Cannes Film Festival on May 17th, 2002: "Bowling for...

May 17th
2:55 PM
Read More

Preying on the Poor: How Government and Corporations Use the Poor as Piggy Banks ...by Barbara Ehren www.michaelmoore.com The trick is to rob them in ways...

May 17th
2:45 PM
Read More

ICYMI, I'll be speaking with Cornel West in a special benefit for New York City's Brecht Forum this Friday, May 18th at 7:00 PM at Hunter...

May 16th
9:27 PM
Read More

Palin's rhetoric torpedoed Medicare savings ...by Wendell Potter www.michaelmoore.com Palin so poisoned the well that not a single Republican will go...

May 16th
1:31 PM
Read More

'Occupy This Album,' with 99 songs performed by David Crosby & Graham Nash, Steve Earle, Tom Morello, Willie Nelson, Ani DiFranco, Third Eye...

May 15th
10:15 AM
Read More

Deficit Reduction: The Great Distraction ...by Dean Baker www.michaelmoore.com Once again our "leaders" are distracting the public from the...

May 15th
10:13 AM
Read More

In the “Loop” with Morello Standing Against ‘Grotesque Income Inequality’ ...by Donna Smith www.michaelmoore.com I listen to the lyrics of one of Tom’s songs...

May 14th
6:06 PM
Read More

This week's This Modern World on DailyKos: Daily Kos: The Austerions www.dailykos.com Readers should imagine the Austerions speaking in full, booming...

May 14th
2:44 PM
Read More

Plutocrats Deserve Public Scorn ...by Carl Gibson www.michaelmoore.com The only way to get the GOP (Guardians Of Plutocracy) out of office is to vilify them...

May 14th
2:13 PM
Read More

One thing I'm sure of: college students will not take this abuse much longer. The rumblings are everywhere. Student Loans Weighing Down a Generation...

May 14th
5:16 AM
Read More

Mother's Day for Peace www.youtube.com Gloria Steinem, Vanessa Williams, Felicity Huffman, Fatma Saleh and Alfre Woodard read the Mother's Day...

May 13th
5:48 PM
Read More

Militarization of the Mothers: You've Come a Long Way, Baby, from Mother's Day for Peace ...by Colee www.michaelmoore.com The five most powerful...

May 13th
5:13 PM
Read More

Happy Mother's Day to all the mothers out there. Here's where the idea came from: Mother's Day Proclamation, by Julia Ward Howe, 1870...

May 13th
4:59 PM
Read More

...and here's my segment talking to Rachel about the Silverdome, and how Michigan is capitalism's laboratory: Rachel Maddow Show www.msnbc.msn.com...

May 12th
3:12 PM
Read More

Here's the segment from The Rachel Maddow Show just before I was on, about the Pontiac emergency manager selling the Silverdome for $500,000: Rachel...

May 12th
3:08 PM
Read More

Subscribe to Mike's Blog RSS

Click here to suggest an article

Mike's Blog

See More Blogs

Vew the archives

View older articles