| Let's
All Hop in a Ryder Truck
Since making Roger & Me in 1989, I've listened
to a lot of stories from people, strangers in the street,
who want to buy me a beer or a burger and tell me what
happened to their American Dream. Roger & Me
chronicled how the world's richest corporation, General
Motors, destroyed my hometown of Flint, Michigan, by
firing 30,000 workers during a time when the company was
making record profits. I filmed my search to find the
chairman of GM, Roger Smith, and tried to convince him to
come to Flint so he could see what he had done to the
people there.
Although Roger never made it to Flint, a lot of other
people have. These days everyone, it seems, lives in
their own Flint, Michigan.
The stories I hear are pretty much the same, with a
few variations to allow for the pink-slipped brother who
committed suicide, or the mother who lost her life
savings when the pension fund went belly-up. I have heard
so many of these stories that I can fill in the blanks
before the sentences are finished. I find myself doing
this to keep from sinking into an even greater despair.
It is not pleasant when a homeless person actually knows
you and calls out, "Hey, Mike!" as you are
trying to walk quickly past him and his shopping cart.
This happened to me on 46th Street in New York City in
front of the Paramount Hotel. I was with a vice president
of NBC and the producers of my show "TV
Nation." The homeless man grabbed my hand for a
shake and told me he, too, was from Flint, Michigan, but
now lives here on the street.
He wanted to describe his favorite part of Roger
& Me, which he had seen three years ago when he
had a job. While the NBC executive was watching in
disbelief, I'm thinking to myself ... I know this guy!
"You remember me, don't you?" he asked.
"I used to deliver your newspaper, the Flint
Voice."
Why was it him standing there like that? Why not me?
But for the grace of Warner Bros. and NBC? I emptied my
pockets and gave him everything I had. We left him on the
street and went inside, where I had a $30 steak. The NBC
suit had a salad. My buddy from Flint was probably
already guzzling his aptly named Colt .45.
еее
As I write this I am on a plane to Ames, Iowa, to speak
to a group of students and farmers who, like the
strangers in the street, are angry and depressed that the
America they once believed in has all but told them where
to get off. When I arrive, the auditorium is overflowing.
I begin to hear the same stories of betrayal and
bewilderment and, always, the Big Question. Why is it
that if they worked so hard for so long, and played by
the rules, and voted for the Republicans, their reward
has been foreclosure and divorce, bankruptcy and
"the bottle"?
As I sit offstage listening to the introduction, I
think about how I, too, was raised to believe in an
America where everyone had the opportunity to achieve a
decent life. I was the all-American boy, an Eagle Scout.
I won my Marksman certificate from the NRA. I was
religious, attending the seminary in high school to
become a Catholic priest. I obeyed all the rules (to this
day, I have yet to smoke a joint) and worked within our
political system (at the age of eighteen, I was elected
to public office in Michigan). Until the 1990s, I never
earned more than $17,000 a year. I have stood in the
unemployment line at least three different times in my
life and was collecting $98 a week in
"benefits" when I decided to make Roger
& Me.
Now, after years of living when I barely had enough
money to even go to the movies, I find myself suddenly
blessed with the opportunity to make them. I feel
truly privileged to be able to speak to so many people.
But tonight, I can't stop thinking about the two people I
met on my way here to Ames.
"Bill" is what the name read on his shirt,
as he stood under the big Delta logo (you'll love the way
we fly) behind the airline counter. He took my ticket,
looked at the name, looked up at me (one of those
"you look so much thinner on TV" looks), and
smiled.
"I just saw your movie for the third time,"
he said, his face turning red because he thinks he's
meeting a movie star or something. "I just want to
thank you for what you did."
I thanked him for thanking me and then he told me his
story.
"I'm fifty years old. Worked here at Delta for
twenty-one years. Two years ago, they announced they were
downsizing the company and told me I was being laid off.
I went into shock. Almost twenty years with the company.
Where was I going to get a job at fifty years old? They
told us they were bringing in outside part-time
contractors to do our jobs. Temps. We were welcome to
apply for those jobs if we wanted toat half our
former wage. I just couldn't do it."
"So," I interrupted, "how many
prescriptions did you eventually go on?"
"Six," he replied, without missing a beat.
"Prozac, Xanax, Pepcid, Lasix, Clonidine for my
blood pressure ..."
"... And something to help you sleep at
night."
"Yeah, Ambien, how'd you guess?"
"I get stopped a lot. People who have lost their
jobs want to show me their portable pill casesyou
know, a little compartment for each day of the week
or"
"Or each pill compartment divided by color,"
he said, finishing my sentence as he pulled out his
plastic medicine chest to show me.
"You're not flying this plane I'm taking, are
you?" I asked half-seriously.
He told me that the only way he got to
come back to work was because someone had died and he was
highest on the seniority list. "I'm down to three
pills a day," Bill said, mustering a little pride.
"Things are looking up."
еее
The cabbie on the way to the airport had also seen Roger
& Me.
"Hey, you're that guy, Roger Moore," he said
as he turned around.
"Yeah." I don't tell him my name is Michael.
I probably should. Michael Moore, son of Frank and
Veronica, brother to Anne and Veronica, no relation to
007.
"I have two master's degrees," he began.
"I've been laid off from two different jobs in the
last five years. Nobody wants a guy with this much
education. So now I'm driving a cab."
"I'm supposed to be in Flint building
Buicks," I tell him, "but I quit the day I was
to start. Many years ago."
The cabbie glanced at me in the rearview mirror,
probably glad I wasn't the one who had built his
Buick. "I've got a question for you, Mr. Moore. Why
is it that Al D'Amato and the rest of Congress have spent
TWO YEARS and TEN MILLION DOLLARS investigating why
sevenseven, mind youSEVEN people lost
their jobs in the White House travel office and not a
single dime or day has been spent investigating why
Thirty MILLION other Americans have lost their
jobs? WHY IS THAT?"
"I've got a few ideas," I reply, but before
I can offer them, he answers the question.
"Because the Big Guys who threw us out of work
are the same ones paying these politicians to keep the
country distracted with some phony Whitewater issue. Any
fool can see that."
еее
We are kind of crazy, aren't we? Today, we're actually
earning less than we earned, in real dollars, in
1979. Millions of people officially are out of
work7,266,000. But the Bureau of Labor Statistics
and the Census Bureau estimate another 5,378,000 are also
unemployed but uncounted. Another 4,500,000 more
are working part-time but looking for a full-time
job. And then there are the 2,520,000 Americans who are
working full-time and earning a wage that is below the
poverty line.
That's nearly 20 million people who cannot make the
bare minimum they need to survive.
Meanwhile, the chief executive officers, the CEOs of
our top 300 companies, are earning 212 times what their
average worker is earning. As these CEOs fire thousands
of employees, they, in turn, become even wealthier.
AT&T chairman Robert Allen lays off 40,000 workers
while making $16 million. Louis Gerstner of IBM fires
60,000 workers, then takes home $2.6 million. Scott Paper
fires 11,000 people, merges with Kimberly-Clark, and CEO
Albert Dunlap bags $100 million!
These corporations then go on to post record profits.
And how do they celebrate their success? By firing even
more people! General Motors made $34 billion in profits
over the past fifteen yearsand eliminated over
240,000 jobs.
Yet, with every round of firings, the societal
problems we must deal with rise at a corresponding rate.
According to a study conducted by economists at the
University of Utah, for every 1 percent rise in the
jobless rate, homicides increase by 6.7 percent, violent
crimes by 3.4 percent, crimes against property go up 2.4
percent, and deaths by heart disease and stroke rise by
5.6 and 3.1 percent, respectively.
No matter how rosy Washington tries to paint the news
about the economy ("The lowest rates of unemployment
and inflation in years!"), the average American
knows that the jig is up. No one, these days, can
remember what job security used to feel like because
everyone lives in total fear that he or she could be
next. No one is safe. So you learn not to complain as you
are forced to work longer hours for lower pay. Health
benefits? Paid vacations? You've already kissed them
good-bye.
Remember the American Dream? For those of you too
young to have ever experienced it, this is what it used
to be:
If you work hard, and your company prospers, you, too,
shall prosper.
That dream has gone up in smoke. Now it's the American
Bad Dream:
You work hard, the company prospersand you lose
your job!
There is no more telling sign about the state of the
union than this one simple fact: Manpower, Inc.the
nationwide temp agencyhas surpassed General Motors
as the number one employer in America. More people now
work for a company that guarantees you a job for a day
than for the world's largest manufacturera company
that once proclaimed "What's good for General Motors
is good for the country."
We all know it's over, this way of life we once had,
or thought we could have if we put in a decent day's
work. Now we must fight each other for whatever scraps
are left, leaving the rich to enjoy the greatest wealth
this country has ever seen.
From the look of things as I've described them, you'd
think the whole country would be up in arms over how the
well-to-do have gotten away with bloody murder. You would
think that we'd have mass political movements organizing
the middle class and the working poor. You would think
new political parties would be forming to stop this
destruction of the American Dream.
You would think that, but you would be wrong. Instead,
the majority of Americans have decided that the best
statement they can make is no statement at all. In the
1994 election, more than 60 percent of all voting-age
Americans118,535,278 people, or the equivalent of
the voting-age population of 42 stateschose to stay
home and not participate. They did so not because they
are apathetic or ignorant or careless. They didn't vote
because they have had their fill of it. The candidates
and the two political parties no longer have anything to
say to the citizens of this country. The Democrats and
Republicans are so much alike, obediently supporting the
very system that has brought ruin to so many families,
that the average American couldn't care less what any of
them have to say. They know that voting will not improve
their lives, not one single bit.
It is significant to note that, in the 1992
presidential election, nearly 20 percent of those who did
vote actually took the time to drive to the polls and
stand in line to cast their ballot for a man most of them
knew was a certified fruitcakeRoss Perot. That's
how intense the level of anger is in this country.
Millions threw away their vote simply because they
thought it would send a message! Perot, as nutty as he
is, was saying a lot of the things that no one else was
saying about the American workera real irony
considering the billions he owns and the fact that his
Democratic opponent, Bill Clinton (raised by a single
mother, at times impoverished), said little or nothing.
It is even more surprising that in 1996 a majority of
Americans said that if they had the chance, they would
elect Colin Powell as president. That so many of these
downsized Americans would be able to push through their
own personal racism just so they could send a message
about how angry they were over their plight was a
powerful signal that all is not well in the U.S. of A.
Did you ever think things would get this bad in America
that you would live to see the day when a majority of
white voters pleaded for a black guy to run for
president? They would never want him to move next door or
marry their daughterbut they would put him in the
highest office in the land! Wow.
In my home state of Michigan, the situation has sunk
so low that only 12 percent of the voters went to the
polls in the March 1996 primary, even though at that time
there was a bitterly contested race between Bob Dole and
Pat Buchanan. Buchanan knew firsthand just how bad things
have gotten for the countryin part because he had
spent most of his life in the Nixon and Reagan White
Houses making it bad. But now he had transformed himself
overnight into The Great White Workers' Hope. Like a man
who had preceded him on the political scene over sixty
years ago (albeit in Germany), Buchanan knew just what to
say to the disenfranchised, abused American worker: HATE!
FEAR! MORE HATE! BLAME THE IMMIGRANTS!
He almost pulled it off, getting about a third of the
Republican vote, even winning a few states. It speaks
well of the goodness of the American people that they did
not fall for his ruse. It is very easy to manipulate
people when they are down on their luck. Very easy to
plug in to their psyche with all the "right"
answers to "Who did this to you?"
Many citizens, though, are not just sitting idly by
watching their country go down the drain. In October
1995, one million African-American men marched on
Washington, D.C., to let America know they had had it. It
did not matter to most of them that the march was led by
a weirdo. What mattered was making the statement. And did
they. One out of every ten black men in this country
found a way to get to Washington, D.C., that day (the
equivalent of 8 million white guys holding a
demonstration). It made a powerful impression on an
already frightened white America.
Just how frightened is evidenced by the growing
militia movement. Tens of thousands of men and women are
training, with weapons, for what they believe will be the
ultimate confrontation with the government. Although most
of them are motivated by racist beliefs, a lot of their
sympathizers are just the average Joes who live next door
to you. But not for long. The bank has foreclosed on
their house and repossessed their car and the money they
had put away to send the kids to college is now used to
buy food, clothes, and maybe someday a few semi-automatic
weapons. They have, in essence, snapped. It's one thing
to have always been poor and never possessed those
niceties of middle-class life. It's a whole other thing
to have enjoyed those privileges and then have them taken
away from youby the very people you voted for!
When that happens, many individuals who are already on
the edge and can't figure out how to respond po-litically
are going to do one of two things: (a) Take it out on
themselves (sit in the dark and drink), or (b) Take it
out on you. In Michigan alone, the birthplace of
downsizing, there are over fifty militia groups, the most
in the country.
еее
My parents called yesterday to tell me that GM has
announced two more plant closings in Flint (are there any
left to close?). Another 3,000 lives will be torn apart.
Some of these people who will lose their
jobs are recent arrivals from Oklahoma City. They moved
to Flint (a few months after the bombing of their federal
building) when GM began laying off workers at its factory
there and told the ones with higher seniority that they
could relocate to Flint if they chose. So they rented
their Ryder trucks and headed to Michigan with the
promise of the company that they would be secure (in
Flint!). Now, nine months later, they will be forced to
call Ryder Truck and move again. They've been told this
time that they can go to Lansing.
еее
What is terrorism? There is no question that, when an
individual rents a Ryder Truck, loads it with explosives,
and blows up a building, it is an act of terrorism and
should be severely punished.
But what do you call it when a company destroys the
lives of thousands of people? Is this terrorism? Economic
terrorism? The company doesn't use a homemade bomb or a
gun. They politely move out all of the people before they
blow up the building. But as I pass by the remnants of
that factory there in Flint, Michigan, looking eerily
like the remnants of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal
Building in Oklahoma City, I wonder: What will happen to
those people? A few will kill themselves, despondent over
the loss of their livelihood. Some will be killed by
their spousean argument over the lack of a new job
or the loss of money at the racetrack turns suddenly
violent (the woman is the one who usually ends up dead).
Others will be killed more slowly through drugs or
alcohol, the substances of choice when one needs to ease
the pain of his or her life being turned upside down and
shoved into an empty, dark hole.
We don't call the company a murderer, and we certainly
don't call their actions terrorism, but make no mistake
about it, their victims will be just as dead as those
poor souls in Oklahoma City, killed off in the name of
greed.
There is a rage building throughout the country and,
if you're like me, you're scared shitless. Oklahoma City
is the extreme extension of this rage. Though most people
are somehow able to keep their wits through these hard
times, I believe thousands of Americans are only a few
figurative steps away from getting into that Ryder Truck.
How terrifyingly ironic that the vehicle now chosen for
terrorist acts is the same one used by that vast diaspora
of working-class Americans who have spent the last decade
moving from state to state in the hopes of survival.
This moving van, this symbol of their downsized lives,
has become a means to an end. Eighty pounds of fertilizer
and a fuse made of ammonium nitrate and fuel oil now fill
the trusty Ryder instead of the kids' bunk beds and the
dining room set.
Timothy McVeigh couldn't get a decent job in Buffalo,
so he joined the army and got the "first kill"
of his unit in Iraq during the Gulf War. We gave him a
medal for that kill, that taking of a human life. That
murder was sanctioned because he was doing it on behalf
of Uncle Sam for the oil companies.
The next year, he was unemployed, hanging around
Niagara Falls, New York. A photo of him that has been
widely published shows him and fellow defendant Terry
Nichols horsing around on the ledge at Niagara Falls. I
was there at the Falls, writing and prepping my film
Canadian Bacon, at the time that photo was taken. I, of
course, have no recollection of seeing McVeigh there,
because who was he then? Just another son of a GM worker
who couldn't get a job, not even as a toll-taker on the
bridge to Canada (he had scored second highest on the
test; there just weren't any openings). In the first
scene we filmed a few months later at the Falls, the
character "Roy-Boy" is a laid-off worker (also
a veteran of the Gulf War) and is on that same ledge,
preparing to jump and end it all.
McVeigh and Nichols had met in the Army. The day that
Nichols decided to join the Army he drove through the
decimated downtown of Flint, Michigan, walked into the
recruiter's office, and signed up for a better
lifebetter than whatever Flint could offer.
After the war (and their stint looking for work around
Niagara Falls), McVeigh and Nichols then moved to a farm
Nichols' brother owned an hour northeast of Flint. They
went to Michigan Militia meetings. They blew up
"things" in the backyard. It was no surprise to
me that McVeigh and Nichols found themselves on a road
that led from Flint, Michigan to Oklahoma City, Oklahoma.
How was it that Timothy McVeigh became so confused and
filled with so much anger? What struck me most about his
alleged act was that he had decided to kill his own
people to make his point. This was a strange twist for
those on the extreme Right who had always used their
violence against blacks, Jews, and immigrants. But
McVeigh is not accused of taking that Ryder Truck to the
place where his "enemies" werethe Capitol
Building, the World Trade Center, a Jewish temple, the
headquarters of the NAACP, or other potential targets of
his hate. No. He blows up his own people! In mostly
white, Christian conservative, Republican-voting,
redneck-lovin' Oklahoma City! Talk about the final
insanity.
I do not like guns. I am a pacifist at heart. As a
member of that minority of Americans who are unarmed, I
am committed to finding a way to combat the downsizing
tide that seems to be rising against us. So I have
written this book. I have no college degree, so take what
I say with that in mind. I'm not even supposed to be
writing this book right now, because I'm under contract
to produce a sitcom I've been hired to write for Fox. A
sitcom! What am I doing with my life? Hell, I still owe
Mr. Ricketts an English paper from twelfth-grade
Shakespeare! How did I ever get here from Flint?
Oh, yeah. In a Ryder Truck.
й 1996 Michael Moore. All rights reserved.
|